“Good vs. Evil”, and the Jewish role in the world

Zsolt Hermann
6 min readApr 21, 2023

--

An interesting conversation from the Internet:

“You wrote that there are no “good vs. evil” people in the world, but we are all born with an inherentluy negative nature we all need to correct. That’s ridiculous, and false equivalency, bruh. If you are the antelope and the leopard has you by the neck, use any tool you have to kill the leopard. That’s not something to have a midnight bullshit dorm discussion about. Your answer is bourgeois garbage.”

Thank you for your response.

I think your example with the leopard and the antelope does not fit here for many reasons. First of all, we cannot look at that scenario in a way that the “evil leopard is killing the poor and innocent antelope.” Maybe this is true in Disney cartoons, but not in real life.

The action of the leopard is solely positive and the leopard simply acts instinctively, according to how the laws of nature determine how it should act.

By killing the antelope – finding and eating the weakest link in the species – helps with natuaral selection, making the species of the prey stronger. Moreover, the leopard consumes only what it needs, leaving the rest of the carcass for secondary predators and scavengers, fulfilling its role in the perfectly balanced “circle of life” in nature. Without the top predators fulfilling their roles, the balance would be broken and there would be mass extermination of the rest of the species in the ecosystem as a result.

Human beings do not act “naturally”, thus at this stage we cannot compare ourselves to nature.

We instinctively exploit and overconsume everything we can. We exist and behave against the laws of nature and against the general balance and homeostasis. Only how much opportunities and abilities we have to exploit others and nature differentiates between us.

Given the chances and conditions we would all turn into “evil”. The infamous Stanford experiment for example proved this very clearly, but we can see unlimited examples of this selfish and exploitative human behaviour from history and from our own, day-to-day life. We are all programmed the same way, and when the “oppressed” gain control, they start acting exactly the same way as the previous oppressors. Human history shows very sharply this helpless swing from “left to right and right to left”.

I fully understand that you do not like what you hear, but that does not make it untrue.

Just watch life unfolding and you will see that especially those who claim to be “good”, those who claim to have higher moral values and follow “enlightened and progressive” ideologies how hateful and intolerant they are, trying to censor, oppress and destroy anybody who does not follow their “politically correct” agenda.

Finally, I am not sure what you find “bourgeois” in what I wrote. If you want to associate the natural, scientific method I am studying and publicizing with any present ideology or system, Communism with its idea of mutual responsibility, mutually complementing integration would be the closest. But it is not Communism, since the way Communistic ideologies have been forced on people so far inevitably lead to the most evil and oppressive systems in history.

If we want to build a truly good human system, rising above our inherently “evil” nature, then we all need to willingly and consciously change and further develop ourselves with the help of the right educational and scientific method.

“ So Hitler made the Jews very smart by killing 6 million average ones. OK, bruh. Welcome to the jungle.

The Jews were victims due to weakness. They did not have to take on the Wermacht. Just kill the 20 oligarch families that put him in power for their enrichment. 5 were in the US. Then decapitate the Nazi hierarchy, another 20 people. Believe people when they promise to exterminate you. Act. Do not just lay about. Kill first.

By the way, 7 million Germans were killed too. Jews would have helped Germany, by preventing its return to the Stone Age for a decade.

Your defense of Commie is morally disgusting. It is unnatural. It can only be imposed by killing 100 million. It and its collaborators are pure evil.”

Again, thank you for your response.

I am not sure if you read everything I wrote about Communism, or perhaps I did not express myself properly.

I am definietly not condoning how humanity implemented Communistic ideas, as all Communist regimes lead to oppression, terror and mass suffering of people. I simply replied to your suggestion that my ideas were “bourgeois”, trying to explain that if you want to try resemblence to what I am trying to explain within available ideologies, then Communistic ideas – like mutual responsibility, mutually complementing cooperation above and against self-interest would be the closest.

But the method I am studying and promoting has nothing to do with actual Communism, what I try to explain is how humanity needs to change, by learning mutual responsibility and mutually complementing integration from nature’s finely balanced and mutually integrated system. Not based on human ideology, but based on the laws of nature.

Human beings by default, are incompatible with, opposite to nature. This is why we see nature in a false and distorted way and any comparisons between nature and humanity are misguided and misleading.

Until now, human history and evolution was solely driven and governed by the 100% self-serving, self-justifying, subjective and individualistic human ego. Human history equals the chronicle of the development of the ever-intensifying and increasingly ruthless human ego.

What happened in Nazi Germany, for example, is not the action of Hitler or a group of people around him. What happened in Germany, and all other such events and “turning points” in history simply, necessarily and automatically unfolded by the drive of the ego in each and every human being. If it was not for Hitler – or Napoleon, Mao, Stalin, etc. – it would have unfolded through a different character possesing similar attributes, being in the “right place and the right time”.

We cannot change anything and cannot stop the helplessly recurring vicious cycles as long as we blindly and instinctively follow our inherent nature. Even today there are multiple scenarios in multiple places where very similar events to what happened in Nazi Germany could happen again, with the whole world standing by or joining in. If, for example, Iran attacked Israel with nuclearn weapons, or certain countries started rejecting Jews from their nations, who would stand against it or prevent it?

Since you mentioned the Jews, – as a Jew myself, who was born in Hungary, lost family members in the Holocaust, feels like an Israeli – I can tell you why Jews were weak during the Holocause and walked into the concentration camps like sheep going to slaughter. The Jewish nation was established on a very special nagtional unity, a so-called “mutual guarantee”, where each member of the nation is totally and absolutely responsible for every other member of the nation. When this mutual guarantee is patent, Jews are strong and succeed. When mutual hatred replaces “brotherly love”, Jews find themselves in mortal danger.

Before and during the Holocause there was total separation and ignorance between Jews. Those – for example in America or Palestine – could have helped, ignored the plight of the Eastern European Jews. German Jews – like American Jews today – cared only about their wealth and their high social poistions they achieved in their adopted country. In the lack of unity and mutual guarantee, Jews were an easy prey.

Fast forward to today, Israel is on the brink of civil war, the nations enemies do not even have to attack, they could simply wait until the Jews destroy themselves, like they did over 2000 years ago before and during the fall of the Second Temple in Jerusalem.

Why is this important for the rest of the world?

Because the Jews have the method of building nature-like mutual integration and unity above and against the inherenly cancer-like human nature that consumes all of us. Jews need to show the positive example of how to survive despite being born self-destructive.

There is no other solution for humanity’s problems ands all the evil we see and experience in the world, but this method that can help us willingly and methodically change ourselves – without any coercion or misleading propaganda.

--

--

Zsolt Hermann
Zsolt Hermann

Written by Zsolt Hermann

I am a Hungarian-born Orthopedic surgeon presently living in New Zealand, with a profound interest in how mutually integrated living systems work.

No responses yet